Did Lachie Jones really walk to his death? Heartbreak and accusations mark inquest (2024)

But over the past five years, Lachie’s father, Paul Jones, has been critical of the police and vocal in his belief that his son did not walk to the pond.

In 2022, police admitted steps had been missed in the early stages of the investigation and the case was reinvestigated for the second time, ending with the same conclusion with no evidence of criminal liability.

After being confirmed by the Ministry of Justice last August, a 15-day fixture for the inquest into Lachie’s death, held by Auckland-based Coroner Alexander Ho, began at the Invercargill courthouse on April 29.

Over the three weeks, dozens of witnesses including Lachie’s mother, father and half-brothers gave evidence.

The courtroom was often tense, with lawyers for both parents, the police, and the coroner batting questions to the witnesses. Some were, at times, reduced to tears, while others grew irate when accusations were made.

See Also

What happened to Lachie Jones?'It just seems like a bloody botched up police job': Inquest into 3yo Lachie Jones' death gets heatedForensic pathologist tells Lachlan Jones inquest drowning most likely cause of deathLachlan Jones case: Police admit mistakes made in investigation, review ordered

The mother: ‘He was my whole world’

The first to give evidence was Lachie’s mother, Michelle Officer.

Describing Lachie as a vibrant child, Officer recalled their outings to parks and her parents’ house to feed ducks. She shared anecdotes of his fearless nature, and recalled an incident that led her to buy a child harness for his safety.

She spoke about her troubled relationship with his father, Paul Jones, and a deteriorating situation with Jones and her sons Cameron and Jonathan.

Officer and Jones’ relationship ended following a common assault charge against Jones.

Officer detailed the events of the day Lachie went missing. After picking him up from kindergarten, she ran errands, briefly encountering Lachie’s father at the courier depot where they both worked.

Later, while at home, she noticed Lachie had wandered off. Frantically searching with the help of neighbour Deborah Thurston, she experienced moments of panic and confusion before calling police.

Throughout the inquest, Officer faced accusations and scrutiny, chiefly by Jones’ lawyer, Max Simpkins.

Simpkins levelled allegations at Officer regarding her actions preceding Lachie’s disappearance, with insinuations of attempting to establish an alibi.

Officer told the inquest she retrieved Lachie from kindergarten at about 2.30 pm on the day he died, spending approximately 45 minutes at home with him and Lachie’s step-brother, Jonathan Scott.

Simpkins asked: “That’s where your son met his death wasn’t it?”

“You left Jonathan there, and then you went to the [courier] depot at 4pm and told Paul [Lachie’s father] that Lachie was sick. After telling Paul that he was sick and not to come around to the house, you left and then organised the disposal of [the] body didn’t you?”

Officer vehemently rejected the accusation. “How dare you ask a grieving mother that,” she said.

Further questioning delved into Lachie’s medical history and Officer’s response to his disappearance. Accusations mounted, with Simpkins suggesting neglect and suspicious behaviour on Officer’s part.

Simpkins questioned her ability to handle the child, and alleged the drowning of Lachie would have been beneficial to Officer “because you don’t have to deal with your irate boy”.

Officer wept as she responded to the accusations.

“It’s just awful that you’d accuse me of that when you don’t even know what happened. How dare you say that to a grieving mother,” she said.

The half-brothers: ‘There is no way we would have hid my brother’s body’

Jonathan Scott emphasised his closeness with Lachie during his evidence, stating that he’d often taken care of the toddler in their mother’s absence.

He was 16 years old at the time of Lachie’s death.

His relationship with Jones had been good during the early stages of the relationship with his mother, but it soured due to Jones’ behaviour while drinking, he told the inquest.

Jones would return from the pub and “abuse [us] for no reason, after we gave him a ride home”, Scott said.

“You don’t like someone who yells at you.”

Scott faced intense scrutiny from Simpkins, who questioned his integrity, particularly regarding inconsistencies in his initial statement to police, such as a false claim about a cash withdrawal for cannabis.

Simpkins suggested Scott’s actions, or lack thereof, during the search for Lachie indicated negligence, insinuating that Scott chose not to assist while his mother desperately searched for her missing son.

Scott replied that Lachie often played hide and seek, and the severity of the situation had not occurred to him.

Prior to police involvement, Scott briefly participated in the search for Lachie on a nearby street but was subsequently picked up by a friend and was driven to an ATM where he drew $50 cash. While he told police in his statement the money was for his brother, he admitted at the inquest it was to purchase cannabis that evening - a transaction that was made shortly after the withdrawal.

The questioning delved into darker allegations, with Simpkins accusing Scott of involvement in concealing Lachie’s body, suggesting Lachie’s body was stored in a freezer.

Simpkins alleged that while Officer was searching for Lachie, Scott elected to “do nothing”.

“You knew your brother was deceased at that stage didn’t you?”

Scott denied the allegation.

“We have a number of statements on the coroner’s file that say Lachie’s body was frozen, stone cold. Mr Scott, what did you do with his body to make it stone cold and frozen cold?” Simpkins said.

He asked if there was a freezer at Officer’s home: “Is that where you stored [Lachie] before you worked out what to do with his body?” asked Simpkins.

“That’s ridiculous,” said Scott.

Simpkins highlighted a job sheet from a police victim support citing Scott’s apparent reluctance to engage with the representative.

Scott told the inquest this was because he did not want to speak to strangers about his brother’s death.

Older half-brother Cameron Scott, 18 at the time of Lachie’s death, gave evidence from Australia via audio-visual link and faced similar accusations to his mother and brother.

At times he grew angry with Simpkins, and spoke of the “defamatory” framing of his family by the media.

He said the allegations that had been made in the preceding days were “disgusting”.

Scott told the inquest that “it was awesome having two younger brothers” and spoke about caring for Lachie and teaching him various activities.

He had been living with his birth father for several months and was there on the night of Lachie’s disappearance.

Scott was playing video games online with friends when he received two calls from his mother informing him of Lachie’s disappearance. During the second call, she asked Scott for the number of the police.

He told her 555, which she dialled, but a friend on the video game told him it was 111, and Scott then contacted his mother to correct her.

Simpkins questioned the necessity of these calls, alleging they were placed to distance Scott from the situation, which Scott rejected.

The lawyer accused Scott of placing Lachie’s body in the pond, which Scott vehemently denied.

Scott called the accusation “disgusting”.

“There is no way we would have hid my brother’s body,” he said.

Scott admitted to smoking cannabis in the hours after Lachie’s death, stating he “would have done anything to cope with the devastation of losing his little brother”.

He told the inquest he dismissed interactions with a police support person, as he did not want to speak to a stranger about it and had plenty of support from family and friends.

He told the inquest in the years since Lachie’s death, his wife has faced harassment in Gore, with anonymous messages sent to her phone insinuating Scott’s involvement in Lachie’s death.

The father: ‘My son didn’t walk out there’

Paul Jones has been instrumental in bringing about the inquest due to his firm belief that the investigation into his son’s death was marred by police mishandling.

In the weeks before Lachie’s death, Jones had been living with his parents in Invercargill and was there when Officer called him to say that Lachie was missing.

Jones told her: “Nothing better have happened to my son.” He then drove to Gore.

On the way, he made a call to friend Dave Aitken, telling him he knew that Lachie was dead.

Jones confirmed that the allegations put forth by Simpkins during the inquest implicating Lachie’s mother and half-brothers Cameron and Johnnie were made on his behalf.

The father candidly spoke about the discord within Officer’s household and his strained relationship with her other sons.

He acknowledged his drinking issues and volatile behaviour would occasionally lead to confrontations with the elder boys, but told the inquest it was due to his concerns for his son’s well-being, alleging mistreatment from Cameron and Johnnie.

He recalled an incident where Lachie fell from Johnnie’s shoulders, prompting a hospital trip and learning that Cameron disciplined Lachie for misbehaviour with a slap on his hand, resulting in a confrontation from Jones.

Following an arrest for assaulting Officer, Jones recalled telling police Sergeant Hua Tamariki while being transported to Invercargill he was concerned something would happen to Lachie.

Tamariki later gave evidence that their drive was silent.

Jones told the inquest Lachie would never walk or run very far, and he never saw him climb.

Throughout the proceedings, Jones questioned Officer’s version of events, and told the inquest he believed she was a neglectful mother.

“I’m disappointed that they had care of him, and if someone else picked him up that night why isn’t [Officer] trying like I am,” he said.

Under questioning from Beatrix Woodhouse, counsel for Lachie’s mother, Jones said he did not accept the alleged timeline of events established by prior witnesses but if he were to, he still did not believe Officer did everything she could.

“I’m not saying who’s done it but I’m saying my son didn’t walk out there,” he said.

The police: ‘We should have locked the scene down’

The police chain of command on the night Lachie was found remains unclear.

Detective Sergeant David Kennelly, who attended the scene as senior Criminal Investigation Branch officer, told the inquest he believed Senior Sergeant Cynthia Fairley was in charge as the ranking officer for eastern Southland. But Fairly had told the inquest that Tamariki was in charge. Stuff reported that Tamariki told the inquest during his evidence that he believed Fairly was in charge.

Kennelly expressed regrets about the evening in question, acknowledging with hindsight and the subsequent allegations that police “should have locked the scene down”.